Trump Questions Biden’s Autopen Pardons

Two elderly men in suits with American flags

A possible constitutional conflict over presidential pardon authority was sparked when President Trump ruled that Biden’s last-minute pardons for January 6th committee members were “void” because they were purportedly signed by autopen. Similar assertions regarding Biden’s signatures have been made by the conservative Heritage Foundation, which cites the same signature on several documents. Trump said Biden “knew nothing” about the pardons and that the courts should decide whether they were valid in the end.

Trump’s Challenge to Biden’s Pardons

President Donald Trump has issued a forceful challenge to the legitimacy of pardons granted by President Joe Biden during his final days in office. Trump declared that Biden’s pardons for various officials, including January 6th committee members, are “void, vacant, and of no further force or effect” because they were allegedly signed using an autopen rather than by Biden himself. The dispute centers on last-minute pardons Biden issued to protect former congresswoman Liz Cheney, retired General Mark Milley, Dr. Anthony Fauci, and members of the House committee that investigated the January 6, 2021 Capitol events.

The president’s challenge raises significant questions about presidential authority and the constitutional limits of pardon powers. Trump claimed that Biden was personally unaware of the pardons, stating they were processed without his knowledge. “He knew nothing about them, and the people that did may have committed a crime,” Trump asserted. This remarkable claim suggests potential criminal investigations into those who processed the pardons if Trump returns to office, specifically targeting individuals he has previously criticized.

Legal Questions and Constitutional Concerns

Trump’s declaration has prompted debate among legal experts about whether a sitting president can invalidate pardons issued by a predecessor. The U.S. Constitution grants presidents broad pardon power with few explicit limitations. While Trump acknowledged that the final decision would rest with the courts, saying “it’s not my decision” whether Biden’s pardons can be voided, his public stance signals potential legal challenges ahead. The conservative Heritage Foundation has supported Trump’s position, pointing to what they describe as evidence of identical signatures across multiple Biden documents.

“The ‘Pardons’ that Sleepy Joe Biden gave to the Unselect Committee of Political Thugs, and many others, are hereby declared VOID, VACANT, AND OF NO FURTHER FORCE OR EFFECT, because of the fact that they were done by Autopen.” – President Donald Trump

Legal precedent on this issue remains limited. A federal appeals court has previously ruled that presidential pardons do not necessarily need to be in writing to be valid, which may complicate Trump’s argument. Critics warn that allowing a president to void pardons issued by predecessors could establish a troubling precedent, potentially undermining the finality of presidential clemency decisions. The Constitution contains no provision for a subsequent president to rescind pardons based on the signing method used.

Political Context and Motivations

The disputed pardons were issued as Biden left office, widely viewed as preemptive measures to shield officials from potential retribution. Trump had previously suggested investigations into January 6th committee members, whom he described as “guilty of unspecified major crimes.” Biden defended his pardons in a January statement, describing the committee’s work as fulfilling “this mission with integrity and a commitment to discovering the truth” while criticizing attempts to “seek revenge, including by threatening criminal prosecutions.”

“President Joe Biden said in a January 20 statement: ‘The Select Committee fulfilled this mission with integrity and a commitment to discovering the truth. Rather than accept accountability, those who perpetrated the January 6th attack have taken every opportunity to undermine and intimidate those who participated in the Select Committee in an attempt to rewrite history, erase the stain of January 6th for partisan gain, and seek revenge, including by threatening criminal prosecutions.'” – President Joe Biden

Trump’s focus on these specific pardons comes amid broader discussion about Biden’s clemency actions. During his term, Biden set a record for presidential clemency, commuting nearly 2,500 sentences, including over 2,000 for nonviolent drug offenses. In comparison, Trump previously pardoned approximately 1,500 individuals related to the January 6th Capitol incident and commuted sentences for several of his supporters. The dispute highlights continuing tensions over the events of January 6th and reflects the deep political divisions that continue to shape American politics.